A Jesus Worth Dying For: A Review of Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger's
"On The Way to Jesus Christ" | Justin Nickelsen
A Jesus Worth Dying For: A Review of Joseph Cardinal Ratzingers
The Way to Jesus Christ | Justin Nickelsen
Christology seems to have come full circle.
Beginning with Albert Schweitzers Quest
For the Historical Jesus, initiated at the turn of the twentieth century,
and accented with Rudolf Bultmanns existentialist approach, theological
inquiry into the person of Christ has been gradually picking up speed
on a downward spiral, hitting rock bottom in the last many years when
many theologians, under the pretext of licit academic freedom,
have been found writing off even the most rudimentary elements of ecclesiastical
teaching; teachings hammered out in the beginning centuries of the post-apostolic
Most recently, Roger Haightformer president of the Catholic Theological
Society of America (CTSA)was under investigation by the Congregation
for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF) for ideas he forwarded in his book,
Jesus Symbol of God. The inquiry into his work climaxed at the beginning
of this year when the CDF, then under of leadership of Joseph Ratzingernow,
Pope Benedict XVIpublished a notification on Haights book,
claiming that it denied the divinity of Jesus, the Trinity, the salvific
value of Jesus death, the exclusive and universal mediation of Christ
in salvation, and the resurrection.
One would be naive to think that the lack of such notifications on the
part of the magisterium would mean that Haight is a black spot on a white
wall; this could not be further from the truth. In the midst of a quite
telling defense given to the theologian throughout the academic world,
the most appropriate of responses came from Jesuit, Gerald OCollins,
who said, "I wouldnt give my life for Roger Haights Jesus.
Its a triumph of relevance over orthodoxy". Indeed, it is.
It is into this scene that we welcome Ratzingers newest book, On
the Way to Jesus Christ. In this timely collection of essays,
from a scholar who has so often been at the forefront of these debates,
he responds again to the question of Christ: "Who do you say that
I am". While many theologians seem to suggest that there can be no
true and orthodox response to this inquiry, Ratzinger shows that the mystery
of Christ is such that while there are certainly boarders within which
one must swim, theological speculation, faithful to the Church, is like
an oceanvirtually inexhaustible.
It is ironic that the re-construction of the "historical Jesus"
is being taken on by the same strand of thinkers whose philosophical presuppositions
led to the deconstruction to begin with. This "band of scholarship",
notes Ratzinger, "forbids God access to the world" because is
starts with the inference that "history is fundamentally and always
uniform and that therefore nothing can take place in history but what
is possible as a result of causes known to us in nature and in human activity."
"Divine interventions", he continues, "that go beyond the
constant interaction of natural and human causes
cannot be historical."
What follows, then, is a God that has no real activity in the world, and
no revelation in the proper sense."
The Church, in the last 2000 years, has encouraged and kept the sciences
alive, but in the hands of human beings they have honest limits that many
adherents seem unwilling to admit. Ratzinger explains that a science which
begins by asserting an inept Goda God that cannot act supernaturally
in the worldstarts with a tenant that is as un-provable as the notion
of a "Creator". Nevertheless, that does not, and should not,
keep mankind from reaching beyond the scope of this world into the universe
in response their innate thirst for knowledge, and making logical deductions
based on clues found within nature.
While faith is certainly the foundation of Christianity, it is a faith
that "first acknowledges the dignity and scope of reason". "Reason
is critical of religion in its search for truth; yet at its very origins,"
says Ratzinger, "Christianity sides with reason, and considers this
ally to be its principle forerunner"an admittance that sets
Christianity out among the other world religions. Christianitys
believability, nonetheless, transcends the sciences, and one would be
remiss to not acknowledge the witness of martyrdom accompanied by a "renewed
life", on the part of believers, "which reopens our closed horizons."
The Church has historically "regarded conversion to the faith as
a positively intellectual journey, in which man is confronted with the
doctrine of truth and its arguments". Therein man "acquires
a new life companionship", and consequently "new experiences
and interior progress become possible for him."
While the newest Pontiff explicitly and implicitly responds to the crisis
in Christological scholarship throughout the book, his other essays range
from a more "aesthetic" approach, reminiscent to that of Hans
Urs von Balthasarone of Ratzingers greatest influencesand
into a discussion of the Eucharist, including an epilogue reflecting on
the reception of the Catechism ten years after its publication.
A book that the average to more advanced reader can appreciate, On
the Way to Jesus Christ refrains from mere dogmatic regurgitations.
The essays are novel, yet faithful to, and at the service of, the Church,
written by a theologian that swims within the ocean of Catholic thought,
presenting a Jesus that is truly worth dying for.
[A version of this review will be appearing in Lay Witness magazine.
Also, please see
this summary on the Haight notification from John Allen Jr. and this
piece from Zenit.org.]
John Allen Jr., "Doctrinal Jousting: Theologian's Work Raises
Ire of Vatican, as Well as Questions About Authority, Process and the Limits
of Scholarship", in National Catholic Reporter (February 25,
Roger Haight, Jesus: Symbol of God (Maryknoll, New York: Orbis,
Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger, On the Way to Jesus Christ (San
Francisco: Ignatius Press, 2005).
Related IgnatiusInsight.com Links:
Page for Pope Benedict XVI/Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger
Jesus in the Gospel of John | An Excerpt from On The Way to Jesus
Christ | Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger
and Succession | From Called
To Communion: Understanding the Church Today
the Papacy, John Paul II, and the Nature of the Church | From
God and the World: A Conversation with Peter Seewald
XVI's Rookie Year As a Priest | From Milestones:
Truth, Faith, and Tolerance Compatible? | From Truth
and Tolerance: Christian Belief and World Religions.
in Fact Is Theology? | From Pilgrim
Fellowship of Faith: The Church As Communion
excerpts from The
Ministry and Life of Priests | Aug/Sept 1997 Homiletic
& Pastoral Review
to U.M. Lang's Turning Towards the Lord: Orientation in Liturgical Prayer
| Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger.
Justin Nickelsen operates the
"Sources Chrétiennes: Renewal in Catholic Thought"
the Insight Scoop Blog and read the latest posts and comments by
IgnatiusInsight.com staff and readers about current events, controversies,
and news in the Church!