Saint John Paul II? | By Valerie Schmalz | April 16, 2005
Saint John Paul II? | By Valerie Schmalz | April 16, 2005
As the cardinals gear up to enter the Conclave this Monday, April 18th,
many wonder if the new pope will heed calls for speedy Church recognition
of the sanctity of Pope John Paul II.
The answer is, of course, no one knows.
With the magazine Inside
the Vatican and some Italian papers describing the 78-year-old Cardinal
Joseph Ratzinger as an early but controversial vote leader for pope, the
eulogy of the high profile Cardinal for John Paul II increased speculation
among those thinking of early canonization.
John Allen, Rome reporter for the National Catholic Reporter, recently
said "the push for Ratzinger is real" but that the Prefect for
the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith probably does not have the
77 of 115 votes needed for the two-thirds majority required in early voting.
Father Richard John Neuhaus, editor of First Things, also notes in
Diary" blog that Ratzinger appears to be ahead. Under the rules established
by Pope John Paul II, the cardinals may go to a simple majority after a
30th balloting. As Allen observes, "Most forecasts published
in the meantime are simply sound and fury, signifying nothing."
Delivering the popes eulogy on April 8th, Ratzinger recalled that
the late pope blessed the crowd from his window on Easter Sunday, days before
his death. "We can be sure our beloved Pope is standing today at the
window of Our Fathers house, that he sees us and blesses us. Yes,
bless us Holy Father."
Whoever the new pope is, the groundswell of opinion for canonizing John
Paul II recalls the early saints, says the secretary of the Congregation
for the Causes of Saints, Archbishop Edward Nowak. Nowak told the Italian
publication Corriere della Sera that during the Pope's funeral, as
the cries rang out in St. Peter's Square calling for John Paul IIs
quick canonization, "it reminded us of the acclamation of saints that was
the practice in the ancient Church." Nowak said the cause may be opened
as early as the October Synod of Bishops, Catholic
World News website reported.
However, Helen Hitchcock, founding director of Women
for Faith & Family, says, "It is not very fruitful to speculate
about what the new pope will do about canonizing his predecessor. There
was an outpouring of sentiment for canonization immediately after the death
of John XXIII."
Yet the pope who convened Vatican II was only recently beatified.
Jeff Miller, author of the popular Curt
told IgnatiusInsight.com, "I have started to read multiple instances
of other Catholics who have started to ask the intercession of Pope John
For myself, I have found it especially easy to slip into asking
One cardinal revealed the day after Pope John Paul IIs funeral a miraculous
cure by the intercession of the pope and Italian newspapers reported that
the Vaticans Secretary of State already has a dossier of testimonials
from hundreds of people who wrote to John Paul II during his 26-year pontificate
to thank him for curing their terminal diseases.
Is Pope John Paul II a Saint?
Only the Church can canonize, but author Peter
Kreeft says of Pope John Paul II: "He showed us that we have a
saint-detector in us, by being so clearly detectable."
Father Neuhaus believes John Paul will some day be called John Paul the
Great. "He has all thewhat we would callheroic virtues,"
he wrote in his "Rome Diary."
Father John Saward, contributing author to the new book, John
Paul the Great: Maker of the Post-Concilar Church, told IgnatiusInsight.com
in a telephone conversation from Oxford, England that "Heroic charity just
shines forth from the Holy Father. His forgiveness of his assassin. His
making the sign of the cross as he fell to the ground on May 13, 1981."
The Church will make the final determination, Father Saward noted.
The pope believed Our Lady turned the bullets trajectory so it critically
wounded him in the abdomen but did not kill him on the feast of Fatima.
The bullet is now welded in the crown of Mary's statue in Portugal.
Although the Catholic Church has established rules designed to slow the
process, with five years the recommended wait before the cause for beatification
is opened, the next pontiff may waive that as Pope John Paul II did in the
case of Mother Teresa of Calcutta. For beatificationexcept in the
case of martyrdomthere must be one miracle after death; a miracle
must take place after beatification for canonization to occur.
John Paul II proclaimed 1,338 blessed and 482 saints, more than all his
predecessors together since 1588, when procedures for these causes were
"It is well known that Pope John Paul IIs view of formal canonization
was dramatically different from his predecessors," Helen Hitchcock
"He seemed to believe that having many even local models of holiness
would aid people in their own aspiration to become saints (that is, people
who are redeemed by Christ) themselves, and he 'lowered the bar' for the
Churchs proclaiming that individuals have, indeed, achieved their
goal which is the goal of every believing Christian," she noted.
"That is not to say, of course, that everyone who actually becomes
a saint is, or can be, officially proclaimed so through the canonization
process of the Church; nor does canonization mean that those who have been
canonized were flawless in every way in this life."
Among the reported miracles during the pontiffs lifetime, is the case
of Jose Heron Badillo, who was four when John Paul visited his hometown
of Zacatecas, Mexico in 1990. The boy, who suffered from leukemia, was selected
to hold a dove as part of the airport ceremonies to welcome John Paul.
"The pope told him, let the dove fly! Then (the pope) hugged him and kissed
him on his forehead," recalled Mexican Cardinal Javier Lozano Barragan in
an interview published by Corriere della Sera after Pope John Paul
IIs death. The cardinal, who headed the Vatican office on health care
issues under Pope John Paul, said there was no medical explanation for the
boy's subsequent recovery. "They only gave him days to live," he told the
During a commemorative Mass for the pope on the Saturday after the funeral,
Cardinal Francesco Marchiano revealed to the congregation that John Paul
II restored his voice after a bungled operation had damaged his vocal cords
five years ago.
"He caressed where my throat had been operated, telling me, 'Don't
worry, you will heal soon, the Lord will help you speak again'," Cardinal
Marchiano told his congregation in Rome. "After some time, I regained my
voice," Zenit reported.
Italian Cardinal Ersilio Tonini said the crowds clamor for sainthood
"tells us there is a question that the Church must take up, and that
will not go ignored," the newspaper The Australian reported.
"It is important to remember that millions hailed John XXIII as a saint
too and forty years later he is nowhere near canonization," Kathy Schaidle,
author of the blog, Relapsed
Catholic, said of the pope who convened Vatican II and was recently
beatified by Pope John Paul II.
blogger Joshua LeBlanc writes: "When I heard of his death I never had
the feeling of mourning but of rejoicing
Pope John Paul II taught us
much in his death
he taught us that death has lost its sting
in death we should be rejoicing in the resurrection and I dont think
theres any doubt that Pope John Paul II was interceding for us the
moment after his death."
On the blog A Saintly
Salmagundi, Father Bryce Sibley posts a link to the Novena for the
repose of the soul of John Paul II, and asks prayers for his beatification,
"to that end we pray for the miracle of healing for Val Monteiro,"
a youth minister with muscular dystrophy.
Seminarian Joseph Previtali, currently studying in Rome, left this comment
on the Insight
Scoop blog: "A
brother seminarian reports that on the day of the Popes death, his
pastor heard, unusually, at least five-seven confessions from people who
hadnt been to confession in 20-40 years. John Paul II is taking a
lot of people with him on his coat tails into heaven."
Valerie Schmalz is a writer for IgnatiusInsight. She worked as a
reporter and editor for The Associated Press, and in print and broadcast
media for ten years. She holds a BA in Government from University of San
Francisco and a Master of Science from the School of Foreign Service at
Georgetown University. She is the former director of Birthright of San Francisco.
Valerie and her wonderful husband have four children.
If you'd like to receive the FREE
IgnatiusInsight.com e-letter (about every 1 to 2 weeks), which includes
regular updates about IgnatiusInsight.com articles, reviews, excerpts, and
please click here to sign-up today!