China's Struggling Catholics: A Second Report on the Church in Beijing | Anthony E. Clark, Ph.D. | Ignatius Insight | September 13, 2008
China's Struggling Catholics: A Second Report on the Church in Beijing | Anthony E. Clark, Ph.D. | Ignatius Insight | September 13, 2008
Editor's Note: Dr. Anthony Clark, assistant professor of Asian history at the University of Alabama, is in Beijing, China, to spend four months as
director of the University of Alabama Chinese Language and Culture Program in the capital of China. During his time there, he is writing a series of articles for Ignatius Insight
about Catholicism in China; this is the second article in that series. For more about Dr. Clark, see his bio at the end of this article.
In my first report from
China's harried capital ("China's Thriving Catholics: A Report From Beijing's
South Cathedral", August 20, 2008) I described the vibrant parish life in
Beijing's South Cathedral. Now the Olympics are over, the smog has returned,
and the more challenging aspects of practicing the faith in China are more
While optimism is
appropriately in order, there remain many obstacles to free and unlimited
expression of Catholic life in China. Beijing's four major Catholic churches
continue to fill to overflowing, and the emerging and popular new 798 Art
District was recently able to host an artistic photography exhibit of Catholic
life in rural China without government intervention. However, it is still true
that to openly practice Catholicism is to limit one's social opportunities.
Two things are required to
advance in "New China's" political and educational system: a college degree,
which only a small minority of Chinese are able to earn, and membership in the
Communist Party, which is not open to Christians. Nor would Christians wish to
join the Party, which is atheistic and has articulated its official goal to eradicate
religion. Just as the so-called "Patriotic" Church was openly celebrating Mass
around the time of the 2008 Olympics closing ceremonies, an "underground"
bishop was arrested by Chinese authorities. Official tolerance of sanctioned
religious practice is balanced by official intolerance of anyone outside of the
In this installment, I shall
describe Beijing's three other major churches and consider some of the enduring
difficulties of being Catholic in China's modernizing capital. Besides the
South Cathedral, Beijing has three major Catholic parishes: the
Dongjiaominxiang Church, the Wangfujing Church, and the Xishiku Church.
Nestled almost invisibly in
Beijing's old foreign Legation Quarter is the towering Dongjiaominxiang Church,
also called St. Michael's. Facing the former Belgian embassy, St. Michael's is
a gothic building possessing a remarkable history. The Diocese of Beijing's
official record of this church notes that during Chairman Mao's disastrous
Great Leap Forward (1958-1960) and Cultural Revolution (1966-1976), the church
was confiscated by Chinese officials and "occupied by the Dongjiaominxiang
Primary School and Hong He Lou Restaurant" (Dongjiaominxiang tianzhutang, 1). During Mao's rule all religious buildings were
taken by the authorities and reassigned to
secular uses. St. Michael's was not restored to the Catholic community for
liturgical services until December 23, 1989 (Dongjiaominxiang tianzhutang, 1). Presently, St. Michael's church hosts both a
Chinese and Korean community, and it claims a strong tradition of Eucharistic
The most visible and active
Catholic church in Beijing is the Wangfujing Church, or East Church, dedicated
in the seventeenth century to St. Joseph. The original church was destroyed by
an earthquake in 1702, and rebuilt the following year; the famous Jesuit
painter, Giuseppe Castiglione (1688-1766), produced paintings for this church.
East Church was confiscated by the Qing (1644-1911) court during anti-Catholic
persecutions in the mid-eighteenth century and demolished. It was rebuilt in
1884 in the Romanesque style, but was destroyed again by Boxers during the
Boxer Uprising of 1900. It was rebuilt in 1905 in magnificent style, and became
a flourishing Catholic parish until Chairman Mao's era, when the building was
converted into a warehouse. This stunning Romanesque church fell into serious
disrepair until it was returned to the Catholic community and restored in 2000.
I attended a standing-room-only Sunday Mass at this church, and the celebrant
invited new Catholics to recount their conversion stories. Their stories were
summoning accounts of how Christ gave them a peace and sense of truth they've
never known. They also described the fulfillment gained by entering the
Catholic Church. I could not help but reflect on the painful realities they
inevitably face by identifying themselves with Christianity in a largely
anti-Christian country. As I stood waiting for a bus near a Korean Christian
church I overheard a Chinese discussion about how embarrassing and ignorant
Christians were; the anti-Christian rhetoric of the Maoist era still carries
powerful social currency.
The largest and oldest
actual Catholic building in Beijing is the Xishiku Church, popularly called
North Church. This church was the bishops' See from 1860 to 1958, when it was
confiscated by China's government during Chairman Mao's Great Leap Forward
campaign. This is the only church that survived the violence of the Boxer
Uprising, which is surprising given the numbers of Boxers who besieged it.
Professor Joseph Esherick recounts that "the Boxers concentrated most of their
energy on the siege of the Catholics' Northern Cathedral. This was the last
remaining church in the city, and some 10,000 Boxers joined in the siege of
over 3,000 Christians and 40 French and Italian marines" (Esherick, The
Origins of the Boxer Uprising, 307).
The bishop of the church at that time, Pierre-Marie-Alphonse Favier, C.M.
(1837-1905), kept a journal during the siege that movingly describes the drama
of the attacks on the church. According to Mei Qianli, the Boxers assaulted the
church for sixty-two days, and the siege was not stopped until foreign armies
marched into Beijing to restore peace (Mei Qianli, Beijing jiaotang, 64).
The Catholics in Beijing almost
unanimously refer to the North Church as the capital's most beautiful church,
and it is indeed a stunning mix of Western and Chinese architecture. The North
Church today boasts the largest and perhaps the most active Catholic community,
and like all Catholic churches in China, it is comprised of entirely Chinese
parishioners. Since citizenship is presently denied to non-Chinese, the only
non-Chinese persons attending Mass are "foreign guests."
Despite, or perhaps because
of, the cultural homogeny in Beijing's churches, guests are warmly, if not
exuberantly, welcomed. Lay Catholics are stationed throughout each church to
assist and greet guests. I have recently read some Western news accounts of
"Patriotic" Catholic churches with Communist overseers placed in the back of
each Mass to observe Catholic activities. This is romantic contrivance; the
people with official badges in the rear of Catholic churches in China are lay
volunteers who watch the church facilities during Masses and other parish
activities. In fact, if you speak Chinese and can speak with these "overseers,"
they are a valuable source of information regarding popular devotions in China.
Lest my account appear blindly buoyant I should note some of the persisting
problems with the "Patriotic" association in China presently.
While the devotional life of
China's Catholics is indeed rich and pious, priests of the "Patriotic"
association are required to avoid aspects of Catholic teaching that contradict
the country's national policies. Abortion and contraception, for example, are
not topics you will hear addressed in a "Patriotic" Catholic church. While
generalization can often be unfair and misrepresentative, it is, I believe,
accurate to note that there is a general sense of disconnectedness with the
Pope among Catholics who attend the "Patriotic" associations services. Other
than a very few token images of Pope John Paul II, I have only seen a single
image of the present Pope, Benedict XVI, in any Beijing church under the care
of the "Patriotic" association. The Pope is certainly mentioned in all Masses
in China, and there is a general sense of his pastoral leadership, but
awareness of his day-to-day teachings and news regarding events and trends in
the Vatican are nearly non-existent on a popular level. Priests are
additionally not allowed to consult China's national archives, so they are
restricted from researching the Catholic history in their own country. As one
bishop informed me, the official history disseminated by state agencies about the
Church in China is often filled with errors and misrepresentation.
One peculiar reality about
the Catholic Church in China is that while it is incorporated into the
Universal Church, it is nonetheless not racially and culturally "universal."
While the hierarchy of Church in China before the Communist era began in 1949
was largely comprised of Western missionaries, it is now entirely run by native
Chinese. On the one hand it is sensible to have a native clergy and hierarchy,
while on the other hand such racial and cultural homogeny creates an atmosphere
of closed-ness and excessive independence. If I may render a polite criticism
of the priests of the "Patriotic" Catholic Church: they tend to speak in an
overly Nationalistic tenor. Bishops are referred to as the "People's bishops";
that is, they are "selected by the People." In fact, during a meeting with an
auxiliary bishop I was directed to refer to him as "Father" rather than
"Bishop," since he was "selected by the People," and is thus "one of the People."
While all are ultimately equal in the view of Christianity, their respective
positions are not.
Also, despite the fact that
the Patriotic Church is by and large in open communion with the Roman Pontiff,
the bishops of the "Patriotic" Church are, at least in public discourse,
"selected by the People," rather than the Pope, to whom God has given charge of
this responsibility. This said, as I met with the bishop, who I uncomfortably
called Father, we discussed one of his prized possessions, a large photo of him
and Pope John Paul II in a warm embrace. Despite the circumstances of his
election and consecration to the episcopate, he was notably and emotionally
attached to the God-appointed pastor of the Catholic Church. If China's Church
is complexly awkward, it is also devoted to the faith it preaches.
Finally, I should say
something of the emerging young Chinese Catholics, who display a refreshing
zeal and optimism for the future of their faith. I am writing this report just
after returning from Mass at one of Beijing's lesser-known churches, the
Xizhimen church, dedicated to Our Lady of Mt. Carmel. It is at this church that
an image of Pope Benedict XVI appears on the bulletin board near the church's
entrance. Before and after Mass I was approached by several college-age
Catholics who had earned degrees abroad, and had returned to China with a sense
of the rest of the Catholic world. Mass had a more international character at
Xizhimen church, though it was an admixture of awkwardly stitched together
liturgical traditions and languages. The music was largely in English, Mass was
in Chinese, and the prayers after Mass were intoned following the musical
patterns of Buddhist chanting. Receiving Holy Communion on the hands is
relatively new to China, and to assure proper reverence for the Body of Our
Lord, hand sanitizer swabs were distributed to each communicant before
receiving the Host. After Mass, I briefly met with the parish priest, who
warmly welcomed me to his church, and the young organist—a graduate of a
Canadian university—agreed to have lunch with me to discuss Catholic life
in China today.
The young men and women of
China seem optimistically dismissive (or na•ve) of China's political turbulence
over the past several decades, looking ahead to a Church that is more and more
free from state control, and a Christian life that accepts the challenges of
the world with joyful expectation. The Beijing diocese today has over 100,000
Catholics, fifty-five priests, fifty nuns, and around twenty seminarians. No
one understands the persistent antagonisms between the Church in China and the
government in China better that the Chinese Catholics themselves, but as the
bishop of Beijing, Li Shan, asserts, quoting St. Paul, China's Catholics
ultimately live "for the proclamation of the Gospel and for the sharing of the
Good News of Jesus with others" (1 Cor. 9:23).
Related IgnatiusInsight.com Articles and Excerpts:
China's Thriving Catholics: A Report From Beijing's South Cathedral | Anthony E. Clark, Ph.D. | August 20, 2008
Two Chinese Churches? Or One? | Anthony E. Clark, Ph.D.
On Writing A History of Christianity in China | Preface to Christians In China: A.D. 600 to 2000 | Fr. Jean-Pierre Charbonnier
Two Weeks in the Eternal City: From the Vatican Secret Archives to the Basilica
of St. Charles Borromeo | Anthony E. Clark, Ph.D.
Catholicism and Buddhism | Anthony E. Clark and Carl E. Olson
Worshipping at the Feet of the Lord | Anthony E. Clark, Ph.D.
Anthony E. Clark, Ph.D. is assistant professor of Asian history at
the University of Alabama.
He did his doctoral studies at the University of Oregon, where he studied
Chinese history, philosophy, and religion. His more recent research has
centered on East/West religious dialogue. He has also been researching the
history of Catholic martyrs in China and has recently finished writing a book on that subject.
Dr. Clark has presented papers at numerous academic conferences and has
also been a guest on "EWTN Live." and "Catholic Answers Live" to talk about Catholicism in China. He is also a contributing editor
for This Rock magazine.
If you'd like to receive the FREE IgnatiusInsight.com
e-letter (about every 1 to 2 weeks), which includes regular updates
about IgnatiusInsight.com articles, reviews, excerpts, and author appearances,
please click here to sign-up today!