Discerning What Is Christian | The Foreword to Hans Urs von Balthasar's "Engagement With God" |
Margaret M. Turek| IgnatiusInsight.com
Discerning What Is Christian | The Foreword to Hans Urs von Balthasar's Engagement
with God | Margaret M. Turek
Six years after the promulgation of
the conciliar constitution Gaudium et Spes (On the Church in the Modern World), Hans Urs von Balthasar published
this programmatic little book under its original title In Gottes Einsatz
leben.  Both texts aim to set
forth an understanding of the role of the Church in the world. Both appreciate
that a dynamic program of openness to the world is an exigence flowing from her
missionary nature. Indeed, in the years leading up to the Council, von Balthasar
had been urging the Church to dismantle the barriers protecting her from the
world, precisely in order that the Church be free to fulfill her mission. In an
earlier (and equally programmatic) work, Razing the Bastions, von Balthasar had
called for "an ever deeper and more serious incarnation" of the
Church in the world.  Since the Church exists to bring the salvation of
Christ to all, he had argued, she must follow Christ's path of
"descent" into the world and assume Christ's form of life. This
entails acting and suffering for the sake of "the least" among us (Mt
25:40) and bearing responsibility in and with Christ for the destiny of all.
Yet while the Council Fathers in Gaudium et Spes enter into dialogue with the whole of humanity,
recommending measures for the building up of society in the light of the
Gospel, von Balthasar here sets forth "a discourse ad intra, within the Church".  This inward turn on
his part does not signify a turning away from the world. Such a reversal he
could only regard as a desertion of the Christian mission. Rather, von
Balthasar speaks chiefly to the Christian for the purpose of priming him to be
an effective and credible instrument of God's involvement in the world. This preparation
requires above all a reflection on the indispensable elements of Christianity.
"Every program of mission to the world", he insists, "must at
all times contain what Guardini called 'the discernment of what is
As in most of his works, so also here von Balthasar directs our gaze to the
figure of Christ crucified. In beholding him, the discerning eye seizes on
"the whole essence" of the Christian faith: "that we should
understand that the love that characterizes the life of the Trinity has been
manifested in [Christ], and in him has been abundantly proved." 
Abundantly, indeed. For von Balthasar, the hallmark of the true God, that which
renders the mission of Christ wholly credible as God's definitive engagement
with the world, is love that radiates the quality of "excess", the
"ever greater", the "yet more". Deus semper major. In the face of the recklessly self-forgetful
character of God's crucified love, the only appropriate response is summed up
in the Ignatian motto "ad majorem Dei gloriam", and in the Johannine exhortation, "so we
ought to lay down our lives for our brothers" (1 Jn 3:16). The more the
Christian grasps the lengths to which the triune God involves himself for us,
the greater grows his own ambition to live no longer for himself.
This means, to be sure, that the form and measure of God's action in Christ
provides the model for Christian action. Von Balthasar, however, is acutely
aware that something more is involved. If Christian action is to be effective as a sign and instrument of God's saving love, it is
not enough to attempt to imitate the God of Jesus Christ by standing in solidarity
with the poor, the stranger, and the oppressed. Neither the life of the Trinity
nor the life of Christ is to be regarded as a mere paradigm to guide programs
of social and political involvement. The crucial factor is that Christian
action participates in the
absolute freedom of God's interpersonal love. Christ, through his Incarnation
and the bestowal of his Spirit, imparts to us a participation in the infinite
freedom of his divine Sonship, by virtue of which we are made capable of taking
part in his trinitarian mission. Hence the significance and success of our
openness to the world depends upon the Trinity's prior opening of its sphere of
divine freedom to our participation. "Only if we start from this 'Alpha'
will our involvement lead us to the 'Omega' ",  that is, to mankind's
ever greater destiny of solidarity in God as "sons in the Son".
One of the outstanding merits of this little book emerges from these
observations. Without taking up a polemical stance, it is equipped to perform a
prophetic and critical function against a "secularization of
salvation". All that it affirms about God's revelation in Christ as
"an invitation into the realm of... divine freedom"  is pregnant
with the insight that the transformation God intends to effect in us is nothing
less than "divinization". By rousing the Christian consciousness to a
renewed awareness that man's full and final liberation coincides with his
"divinization", von Balthasar enables us "to judge clearly how
basically unsatisfying it is for man ... to have as his ultimate goal the civilizing
and humanizing of the world". 
Another of the book's virtues is that its "program of mission to the
world" eliminates the false dichotomy between action and contemplation.
According to von Balthasar, Christian action derives from and is sustained by
contemplation, even as contemplation has its source in action: for "[w]hat
we are looking at when we contemplate the love of God is 'Christ giving himself in love".  In contemplating this,
God's active involvement, we are spurred to play our part in the action.
A further gain is that Engagement with God can serve as an introduction to the second part of
von Balthasar's massive theological trilogy: Theo-drama: Theological
Dramatic Theory.  In
non-technical language he broadly sketches some themes that are central to and
developed at length in Theo-drama.
Here we can note only a few that highlight the form of Christ's mission to the
world. Christ reveals the essence of true freedom in being obedient "even
unto death" (Phil 2:8). Christ discloses the nature of true power in
letting himself be rendered powerless as a function of boundless love. In
Christ we encounter a love sufficiently free to hand itself over to the
autonomy of the other, a love sufficiently powerful to endure to the end the
forces hostile to love. Indeed with Christ it is a case—the unique case—of
love human and divine, without confusion or separation, bearing
God-forsakenness in atonement for sin, once and for all (1 Jn 2:2; 4:10).
Christ unveils, finally, the fulfillment of human freedom in being raised
bodily from the dead and returning home "to the open spaces of divine
freedom" in the bosom of his Father. Thereby Christ proves that he is the
very embodiment of God's mighty act of liberation". 
All this bears upon the credibility
of the Christian's engagement. "For as Christ of his free love yielded
himself willingly ... to death, and dereliction,"  so the Christian is
called to be at God's disposal in readiness to serve his brothers and sisters
without counting the cost. The credibility of Christian action as an engagement
with God for the sake of the world resides in its grace-engendered likeness to
"the foolishness" of divine love (1 Cor 1:25). Only this form of life
"can penetrate the 'secular world' as 'leaven'."  The costly
discipleship that hazards everything is the mark of authentic Christian
Von Balthasar anticipates our protests. "It will be objected that such a
program of action demands the character of a saint. This may well be; but from
the very beginning, Chris- tian living has always been most credible, where at the
very least it has shown a few faint signs of true holiness." 
Margaret M. Turek
St. Patrick's Seminary and University
Feast of St. Patrick
March 17, 2008
 In Gottes Einsatz leben (Einsiedeln:
Johannes Verlag, 1971). English translation: Engagement with God (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 2008). Henceforth EWG.
 Razing the Bastions (San
Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1993) p. 71. German original: Schlefung der
Bastionen (Einsiedeln: Johannes
 My Work in Retrospect (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1993) p. 103.
 MWR, p. 52.
 EWG, p. 41. My italics.
 Ibid., p. 40.
 Ibid., p. 6.
 Ibid., p. 69.
 lbid., p. 47. My italics.
 Theo-drama: Theological Dramatic Theory in 5 volumes (San Francisco: Ignatius Press,
 EWG, p 27.
 Ibid., pp. 27-28.
 MRW, p. 57.
 EWG, p. 61.
with God | by Hans Urs von Balthasar
The brilliant theologian and philosopher Hans Urs von Balthasar writes about God's involvement with man and man's involvement with God in the Old and the New Testaments. He shows how that
interaction of the divine with the human reveals the meaning of true freedom that man is always hungering for but often strives after in wrong and dangerous ways. He shows that God's free
revelation of himself in Christ is an invitation to enter into the realm of absolute and divine freedom, in which alone human freedom can be fully realized.
From the true Christian there radiates the kind of freedom that is constantly being sought after by the non-Christian. In modern times, the freedom of man is a theme that preoccupies everyone.
Atheistic philosophies are wholly taken up with this preoccupation. The Enlightenment was concerned with the freeing of reason from the "fetters of faith". Marx wrote about freeing man economically,
and Freud wrote of freeing man from the bondage of a past as yet unmastered.
As opposed to those whose search for freedom urges them onward into a barren void, the Christian stands as the messenger of freedom accomplished and a freedom attainable by all. A true
freedom of the sons and daughters of God.
"Just as Love Alone Is Credible captures the essence of the seven-volume The Glory of the Lord, so does Engagement with God explain his five-volume Theo-Drama.
But here he does more: by setting his account of the drama of Christian discipleship against the anti-Christian ideologies of the 1960s he brings his theology to bear on the highest cost of
discipleship--martyrdom--by seeing the martyr as the mirror of God's own involvement in the human race through his own martyred Son. One can hardly read a more sober, and yet exhilarating,
account of what it means to live committed to God's own commitment to the world." -- Edward T. Oakes, S. J. Author, Pattern of Redemption: The Theology of Hans Urs Von Balthasar
Related IgnatiusInsight.com Articles and Book Excerpts:
Author Page for
Hans Urs von Balthasar | Ignatius Insight
Books by Hans Urs von Balthasar published by Ignatius Press | Ignatius Insight
Introduction to Adrienne von Speyr's The Book of All Saints | Hans Urs von Balthasar
of My Thought | Hans Urs von Balthasar
Jesus Is Catholic | Hans Urs von Balthasar | An
excerpt from In The Fullness of Faith
Love Must Be Perceived | Hans Urs von Balthasar | An
excerpt from Love Alone Is Credible
Authority and the Petrine Element | Hans Urs von Balthasar
Us | Hans Urs von Balthasar
of Anxiety? | Hans Urs von Balthasar | The Introduction to The
Christian and Anxiety
by the Holy Spirit, born of the Virgin Mary" | Hans Urs von
Balthasar | An excerpt from Credo: Meditations on the Apostles' Creed
is Believable: Hans Urs von Balthasars Apologetics | Fr. John R. Cihak
Margaret M. Turek, S.T.D., is Associate Professor of Systematic Theology at St. Patrick's
Seminary and University in Menlo Park, California. She is the author of
Towards a Theology of God the Father: Hans Urs von Balthasar's Theodramatic Approach (2001).
the Insight Scoop Blog and read the latest posts and comments by
IgnatiusInsight.com staff and readers about current events, controversies,
and news in the Church!